|

Construction record keeping: the cost of missing evidence

One of the most common weaknesses I find in both my Commercial Review work and construction payment disputes is also one of the simplest to address: the records were never kept.

Additional work happened. Labour stayed longer than expected. The sequence changed. Someone gave an instruction. The business carried the cost, but nobody recorded enough information to explain what happened, why it happened or what it cost.

At the time, everyone was busy getting the work done. Months later, when payment is challenged or the final account exposes a loss, the same business is trying to reconstruct the answers from memory. By then, the people who knew may have moved on, messages may be difficult to find and the detail has faded.

You do not always know which record you will need. That is why keeping records has to be part of the work, rather than something you start when a dispute arrives.

Seven months later, nobody can explain the £10,000

Consider a familiar situation. A contractor carries out additional work that costs the business £10,000. The team knows about it on site, but the instruction is not properly captured, the additional labour and materials are not identified, and the change does not reach the person preparing the application.

Seven months later, the business wants to recover that cost. The client questions the variation. Who asked for the work? What changed from the original scope? When was it done? How was the amount calculated? Was it already included elsewhere?

These are questions that the team could probably have answered at the time. Now, the variation account has a figure against it but very little evidence behind it. A real cost to the business has become difficult to substantiate and may not be recovered.

The payment dispute is the point at which the problem becomes visible. The commercial control failed much earlier.

Missing records affect more than the final account

There are two problems here. The first is proving the account when payment is disputed. The second is that the business may not have known it was overspending while there was still time to respond.

If additional work is not recorded and reported, it may never reach the variation register, the forecast or the next payment application. Labour can be costing more than allowed without anyone asking why. A delay can develop without a clear account of what caused it or how it affected the work.

By the time the figures show that the project is losing money, the opportunity to question the instruction, agree a valuation, adjust resources or address the cause may have passed.

Good construction record keeping supports decisions during the project as well as the account at the end. It helps the business see what is changing, what it is spending and what needs attention.

Variations, delay and loss and expense need a supporting story

A variation account needs more than a total. It needs a clear explanation of the change and the information supporting its valuation. A delay claim needs a record of events and their effect on the work. A loss and expense submission needs a basis for explaining the additional costs and connecting them to the circumstances relied upon.

An invoice can show that money was spent. On its own, it may not explain why the cost arose, which work it relates to or why another party should pay it. A photograph may show the work, but leave unanswered who instructed it or when the scope changed.

The useful record brings those pieces together. Keeping it does not, by itself, establish a right to payment. You also need to understand and follow the requirements of your contract. But without the supporting information, even a sound contractual position can become much harder to present.

A few minutes at the time can save days of reconstruction

Record keeping does not need to mean lengthy reports. A short daily note, a dated photograph with an explanation, a saved instruction and a simple record of the resources used can be far more useful than an elaborate spreadsheet assembled months afterwards.

When something changes, capture the essentials:

  • What happened, when and where?
  • Who instructed, requested or agreed the change, and where is that instruction recorded?
  • What changed from the planned scope, sequence or programme?
  • Which people, materials or plant were involved, and for how long?
  • What effect did it have on cost, progress or other work?
  • Who needs to know, and what action is required under the contract?

Keep the records somewhere the business can find them. Information held only in one person’s head, notebook or phone is difficult to use if that person is unavailable. Make it clear who records a change, who checks it and who carries it through to the commercial account.

Records need to lead to questions and action

Collecting information is only part of commercial control. Someone needs to look at it. If the labour cost is rising, ask why. If extra work has been instructed, check that it has been recorded, communicated and valued. If progress has been interrupted, establish the cause and the effect while the people involved can still explain it.

A short, regular conversation between site and the person responsible for the account can expose a problem before it becomes an expensive surprise. A variation register, current cost information and clear responsibility for following things up give that conversation something useful to work from.

The process should suit the size and complexity of the business. What matters is that the information reaches someone who can act on it.

Put the habit in place before you need the evidence

Frantically trying to remember what happened is a poor use of time when a project is already losing money or the business is under pressure. It is also avoidable in many of the situations I see.

This is a recurring connection between my Commercial Review and construction payment dispute work. In a review, I look at how instructions, costs and information move through the business, where the gaps are and who is responsible. In a dispute, those same gaps can determine how well we can substantiate the account.

The starting point is often straightforward: record what happened, keep the supporting information, give someone responsibility and review it regularly. A few minutes each day will not resolve every contractual issue, but they can leave you with a much clearer understanding of your position.

If you are concerned that your records and commercial processes are leaving gaps, contact Michelle Carr to discuss a Commercial Review. If a payment dispute has already arisen, we can assess the contractual position and the evidence available, then recommend what makes commercial sense for the business.

Similar Posts