Construction Payment Disputes and Contractual Support
Know where you stand. Understand your options. Choose a commercially sound way forward.
Discuss your disputeAn honest assessment of your position
Construction payment disputes can put pressure on your cash flow, relationships and the wider business. Whether you are dealing with an unpaid application, disputed variations, deductions or an unresolved final account, you need an honest assessment of your contractual position, the supporting evidence and the likely outcomes.
Axiom One provides independent support with construction payment disputes and other contractual disagreements. Michelle Carr combines quantity surveying and contractual expertise with extensive dispute resolution, commercial management and crisis intervention experience.
We assess the situation, establish whether a dispute has crystallised, recommend a way forward and support your business through to its conclusion. You receive a direct account of the strengths and weaknesses of your position, including gaps in the evidence and the risks associated with each option.
Construction payment disputes: what we help with
We support contractors and subcontractors with payment disputes involving interim applications, final accounts, variations, disputed valuations, deductions and withheld payments.
Our assessment considers what the contract requires, how the account has been prepared, the evidence supporting the sums claimed and the parties’ correspondence. We explain where your position is strong, where it is exposed and what further information may be needed.
We also support other contractual disputes and disagreements between business owners where independent commercial judgement can help establish a way forward.
Is pursuing the dispute right for your business?
The amount in dispute is only part of the picture. Professional fees, management time, disruption and the prospects of recovering payment all affect whether a course of action makes commercial sense.
Sometimes it costs less to pay, compromise or settle than to appoint us to pursue the argument. We will tell you when that is our assessment. Where there is a sound basis to pursue or defend a position, we help you prepare it properly and understand the costs and risks involved.
Support from assessment to conclusion
We begin by understanding what has happened, what each party is seeking and what the contract and available evidence establish. This includes assessing whether a dispute has crystallised and identifying any immediate contractual requirements or deadlines.
For construction payment disputes, this may involve examining payment applications, notices, valuations, variation instructions and the supporting project records. We then recommend a proportionate course of action, which may include substantiating an account, responding to a claim, negotiating a settlement or supporting a formal dispute process.
Our involvement can continue throughout the dispute, keeping the commercial position under review as further evidence, responses and costs emerge.
Legal support, adjudication, arbitration and litigation
Where specialist legal support or formal proceedings are required, Michelle can bring in external support through the legal partners she works with. This can include progressing matters towards litigation, adjudication or arbitration, with the appropriate professional appointments agreed.
We prepare a clear, organised handover of the background, contractual position, accounts, correspondence and supporting evidence. Those taking the matter forward receive a well-presented understanding of the case and the work already undertaken.

Experience behind the advice
Michelle Carr is a contracts expert with extensive experience in construction payment disputes, commercial management, dispute resolution and crisis intervention.
She holds a degree in Quantity Surveying, an HND in Law and a Level 7 NVQ in Senior Construction Management. She is an Associate of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (ACIArb) and a Member of the Chartered Institute of Building (MCIOB).
Her approach combines detailed contractual understanding with practical business acumen: establishing the truth of the position and assessing what each available route could mean for the business.
Case studies
Construction payment dispute: strengthening a subcontractor’s application
A decorating subcontractor was in a payment dispute with a main contractor. Its application lacked sufficient substantiation, and the subcontractor had not fully understood the contractual requirements.
The contract expressly prevented daywork claims without prior written authorisation. Additional work had been instructed, but its cost had not been approved. We used the contract pricing to establish an applicable rate and valued the variation on that basis.
This increased the amount claimed by approximately £10,000. The revised application was accepted and paid.
Final account dispute: establishing the contractual position
Unclear contractual arrangements, incomplete project records and a difficult client relationship had left a contractor struggling to establish and recover its final account.
We examined the contractual position, reconstructed the account from the available evidence and organised the supporting information to distinguish substantiated costs from areas of uncertainty. This provided a clearer basis for negotiation.
The final account was agreed, enabling the contractor to recover project costs.
Resolving a disagreement between business owners
One of two business owners sought support with a disagreement about their business. Through a facilitated meeting, we explored the issues and established that the owners needed different things from the business.
The discussion led to an agreed new direction, an updated agreement between them and a restructuring of the business to accommodate their different needs.
Reducing the risk of future construction payment disputes
Resolving a dispute may reveal weaknesses in contractual arrangements, payment procedures, project records or the allocation of responsibilities. Understanding those weaknesses gives the business a basis for improving how future work is managed.
Where useful, Axiom One can provide further commercial support, including a Commercial Review, to address those findings and strengthen day-to-day management.
Discuss your construction payment dispute
If you are dealing with a construction payment dispute, an unresolved final account or another contractual disagreement, contact Michelle Carr to discuss your position.
Tell us what has happened, what is disputed and whether any deadlines are approaching. We can discuss your circumstances and agree the scope of an initial assessment.
Email Axiom One about your disputeContact Axiom One